Podcasting vs YouTube: Which One is Better for Your Brand?

When it comes to content marketing, both podcasting and YouTube offer powerful ways to build brand authority, engage audiences, and drive business growth. But which one is better for your brand? The answer depends on your business goals, audience preferences, and content strategy. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each platform to help you make an informed decision.

The Case for Audio-Only Podcasting

Podcasting has surged in popularity due to its accessibility and the intimate connection it fosters with listeners. Here’s why it might be the right choice for your brand:

Pros of Audio-Only:

1. Low Barrier to Entry – You don’t need expensive cameras or a studio setup; just a good microphone and a quiet space.

2. Builds Deep Audience Connection – The audio-only format allows listeners to consume content while multitasking, fostering long-term loyalty.

3. Less Competition – While YouTube is saturated with content, the podcasting space still offers room for niche voices to thrive.

4. Longer Engagement Time – People tend to listen to podcasts for extended periods (20-60 minutes), whereas YouTube audiences often prefer shorter videos. 80% of podcast listeners finish an episode. Viewers’ attention spans are most lower.

5. Ideal for Thought Leadership – If your goal is to establish expertise, podcasting enables in-depth discussions, interviews, and storytelling.

6. Podcast SEO is Growing – Platforms like Apple Podcasts and Spotify now offer search optimization features, making it easier for new listeners to find your show.

Cons of Audio-Only:

• Harder to Go Viral – Unlike YouTube, podcasts rely more on word-of-mouth and consistent audience-building rather than algorithmic recommendations.

• No Visual Component – Some industries benefit more from visual engagement (e.g., fitness, cooking, product demonstrations).

• Monetization Takes Time – While sponsorships and ads are an option, monetization usually requires a dedicated audience first. For business podcasts, I recommend using your show as a lead magnet—nurturing relationships, building trust and loyalty, driving listeners to your website. You make the sales, as opposed to your advertisers’ making the sales.

The Case for YouTube

YouTube remains the second-largest search engine in the world, making it an excellent platform for visibility and engagement.

Pros of YouTube:

1. Massive Audience Potential – With over 2 billion logged-in monthly users, YouTube offers unparalleled reach.

2. Highly Shareable Content – Videos can be easily shared across social media, websites, and embedded in blogs.

3. Stronger SEO & Discoverability – YouTube’s algorithm pushes content to new audiences, increasing your chances of organic growth.

4. Monetization Opportunities – Ads, sponsorships, memberships, and product placements provide multiple revenue streams. (Not that you want these in the middle of a business-based video.)

5. Visual Appeal – Great for industries where visuals are crucial, such as beauty, fitness, tech reviews, and tutorials.

6. Live Streaming Capabilities – You can interact with your audience in real-time, boosting engagement and authenticity.

Cons of YouTube:

• High Production Demands – Video content requires more time, equipment, and editing compared to podcasting.

• Shorter Attention Spans – Many YouTube viewers prefer shorter videos, meaning you may not get as much deep engagement per piece of content.

• Algorithm Dependency – Your content’s success is often determined by YouTube’s algorithm, which can be unpredictable.

Which One Should You Choose?

Audio-only podcasts and YouTube videos have overlapping benefits: Nurturing an engaged audience, boosting your brand, developing thought leadership, and making money. So, the choice comes down to whether you prefer to do audio or video. Do you dread the idea of being on camera—especially while referring to a script or notes? Audio-only is the way to go. (But I’ve got lots of tips and tricks to make reading a podcast “script” on video appear that you’re looking right into your listener’s/viewer’s eyes!)

The Best of Both Worlds: Why Not Both?

Some of the most successful brands integrate both podcasting and YouTube into their content strategies. You can:

• Record video versions of your podcast and upload them to YouTube.

• Create short video snippets from podcast episodes for social media. These are much more engaging than sharing static images or audiograms.

• Use YouTube to attract a broad audience and direct them to your podcast for deeper engagement.

My personal recommendation?

Record video and at least share video clips if not the whole video. Editing software such as Adobe Premiere Pro and Descript allow you to edit the video and export as video and audio. No need to edit video and audio separately! This saves you time and money.

While the production value of top YouTubers’ videos is pretty high, a podcast video doesn’t have to be over-the-top. Your video needs to look good (interesting intro/outro with music, nice background, good lighting, being dressed for the part), but the podcast audience isn’t expecting your video to have constant scene changes or splashy graphics.

Currently (December 2024), only 33% of podcaster “listeners” get their podcasts on YouTube. Most people still prefer audio. However, “listenership” on YouTube is growing. Which is kind of weird since the vast majority of podcast listeners listen while multitasking (driving, cleaning, petting the cat).

A huge benefit of sharing your podcast on YouTube is that your show becomes more findable by search engines, especially Google.

Google owns YouTube, the 2nd largest search engine in the world. So, Google is more likely to return a YouTube video or channel than it is an audio podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. (In another post, I’ll share why you absolutely have to put your podcast on your website, not just links to Apple Podcasts and Spotify! Think: Massive boost in SEO for your company.)

(And I’ll share in yet another post how to set up your recording space to look good on video—with some of those tips and tricks to make it look like you’re not referring to a script or notes!)

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your brand’s goals, resources, and audience preferences. Whether you choose audio-only podcasting, YouTube, or both, consistency and high-quality content are key to building a successful brand presence.

---

Podcat Creative Consulting can help you create a strategic, brand-aligned podcast that boosts your brand, your thought leadership, and your bottom line.